To me the article raised several questions. Since my correspondent was at a|
loss to answer my questions, it was suggested to put them out for the list.
Maybe people have some ideas?
1. What do you suppose is the launching mechanism for discharge of raphides
from an intact idioblast? From the picture in the article, the idioblast
looks like a simple bladder filled with fluid. Even at astonishingly high
pressures, the launching power of a liquid is basically nil from a
fixed-volume enclosure. Either we need a gas, which can rapidly expand, or
a flexible bag that can deflate, assuming, of course, that raphides are not
2. How can an idioblast possibly discharge from both ends? If one tip is
breached, the propellant power will be dissipated out that opening, leaving
no more power to launch from the opposite side. If, by impossible luck,
both ends are stimulated simultaneously, two open ends should preclude any
discharge at all. Maybe there is an unseen membrane parallel to the raphide
package that divides the idioblast into two separate chambers, one
discharging one way, the other in the other direction? The physics don't
3. Why is mastication a good way to find idioblasts? Wouldn't I discharge
every idioblast when I masticate? That is why I tried the simple sectioning
at first. I think mastication and settling separation is probably a good
way to gather a large number of raphides. But not intact idioblasts.
4. I wonder how idioblasts are oriented in Diffenbachia tissue. My guess is
that they would be perpendicular to the leaf surface and near it, ready to
fire away. Maybe they are inside regular cells? Maybe they are between
Perhaps there are some adepts on this list that would know the answers to
these questions. Thanks for any help.