IAS Aroid Quasi Forum

About Aroid-L
 This is a continuously updated archive of the Aroid-L mailing list in a forum format - not an actual Forum. If you want to post, you will still need to register for the Aroid-L mailing list and send your postings by e-mail for moderation in the normal way.

  [Aroid-l] Philodendron Santa Leopoldina. Which one is it?
From: "Steve Lucas Exotic Rainforest" <steve at exoticrainforest.com> on 2007.02.14 at 01:28:07(15293)
Philodendron collectors and experts:
This question is lengthy, so I apologize in
advance. There are at least five IAS members who have been
having this discussion privately via email and we'd like to open this question
up to all knowledgeable philodendron growers. ESPECIALLY,
Dr.Gonçalves, Dr. Croat, Simon Mayo, and those in Brazil familiar with
these species!
Almost all serious collectors know of
the extremely rare philodendron in southeastern Brazil known
scientifically as Philodendron spiritus-sancti. Dr. Eduardo Gonçalves and Emerson Salviani published an informative
article in the 2004 edition of Aroideana, volume 21 regarding the
species. According to these experts there are now only 6 known
specimens of that very rare and endangered species left wild in all of South
America. According to a personal email from Dr.
Gonçalves several months ago it is endangered and near extinction due
to the excessive clearing of habitat. The
location of the remaining 6 specimens is closely
In Brazil, P. spiritus-sancti is apparently
known as "Santa Leopoldina". Santa Leopoldina is a town within the same
Brazilian state where Philodendron spiritus-sancti was first located. The name Philodendron
"Santa Leopoldina" was first introduced to the majority of plant enthusiasts in
a 1983 International Aroid Society article by Bette Waterbury regarding her
search for the plant. Bette pointed out there were supposedly 4 variations
of "Santa Leopoldina" in the wild. That is the crux of this
question! Are those 4 variations all variations of the same
plant? Or are they different plants that have a similar blade.
Bette's article appears to imply the primary difference is the color on the
reverse of the leaf, some are redder than others. The true P.
spiritus-sancti is noted on my graphic which you can see in a moment as
species number 1.
Plant sellers been selling a fair number
of vaguely similar species using Philodendron
spiritus-sancti's Brazilian name: Philodendron Santa
Leopoldina. "Philodendron Santa Leopoldina" is not a recognized
scientific name. In effect, it is simply a "common name". But which
of these plants truly deserve the name Santa Leopoldina? You can find
as many as 4 different plants, perhaps more, being sold on eBay using the
pseudo-name Santa Leopoldina II, or III. I
personally own three different plants which were purchased with that name
and none are P. spiritus-sancti.
About a week ago I received this email from expert grower Michael
Paschall in Australia which was accompanied by some excellent photographs
including a photograph of the spathe and spadix of his plants. Those
photographs, and others, are posted on a "blind" link on my website. I
elected to post them blind rather than fill your email boxes with big
photos. Michael wrote, "Eduardo id’d this for me
, it came into Aus. many years ago as a Santa Leopoldina. It has flowered
a few times and has been spread around Qld a fair bit, it grows very well in
sub-tropics. Easily spotted with the d shaped very flat topped petiole
with fine grooves and its tiny internodes." Michael, myself, and others believe his plant is
the species Eduardo is working on now as Philodendron 'Superbum'.
Michael calls it Pseudo-Santa Leopoldina. In the photos this plant,
along with the spathe, is denoted as specimen number
John Criswick from the island of Grenada sent photos to both
Michael and myself of a plant he too knows as Santa Leopoldina. That
specimen has distinctly burgundy undersides but does not have the sharply
pointed upper lobes of the true Philodendron spiritus-sancti. I
too have that plant, mine was a gift from Florida grower Russ Hammer.
Russ knew the plant as Santa Leopoldina. Is it? Michael knows
this plant and one other I recently acquired as 'Roberto'. That is two
different plants known as 'Roberto' as well as Santa Leopoldina.
Those plants are seen on my illustration as numbers 4 and 6. Are these one
of Bette Waterbury's "four variations"? Michael feels due to input from
Eduardo they may be variations of Philodendron atabapoense.
I purchased another plant as Santa Leopoldina which Dr. Croat
identified as either P. angustilobum or P. mexicanum. At
the present size it is difficult to discern which species it may actually
be. But that plant was also sold as Santa Leopoldina and it does not even
come from Brazil! It is from Central America. That plant is noted as
number 5.
I have always had a dislike for common names. How can anyone
possibly know what plant you are speaking of, or buying, if all you have is a
common name? Especially if numerous plants have the same common
name! I am aware that many of these pseudo-names apparently came from
Tropica or Exotica. But still, are they truly worthy of the name Santa
Leopoldina? Should knowledgeable growers be perpetuating a
Rather than put a bunch of photos on this email I have elected to
prepare a graphic on my own website. That graphic is "blind". It is
not published to the web and cannot be found using a search engine. You
can only view it by clicking on this link:
I would really enjoy hearing back from other collectors who may
have other plants not illustrated that were also purchased using the name Santa
Leopoldina. I would especially like to hear from Dr. Gonçalves, Dr. Croat,
Simon Mayo, and any in Brazil who read these posts as to the validity of this
name being bestowed on numerous plants. And, if possible, verify if one of
these plants is 'Superbum' or some as variations of P.
atabapoense. I realize Santa Leopoldina is a region, but can we
honestly call every long bladed philodendron in that region of Brazil Santa
I'd especially like to know if there are, or are not (or were),
four variations of the true Philodendron Santa Leopoldina!
Steve Lucaswww.ExoticRainforest.com

Note: this is a very old post, so no reply function is available.